Beyond.ca

Registration is free! Car Forums - Member Rides Car Forums - Find other members Car Forums - Calendar Car Forums - Frequently Asked Questions Forum Rules and Regulations Car Forums - Search Logout
Beyond.ca - Car Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.3.9 Beyond.ca - Car Forums > Car Forums > General Car/Bike Talk > Replace or rebuild transmission?


Author
Thread
jabjab
Neutral

Location: Calgary
What I drive: TT
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (1)
User Rating: 95%


Replace or rebuild transmission? quote:

I have a 2001 honda crv that I drive for winter that has a newer engine and lots of recent maintenance done.

In order to stop a small oil leak I have had both axle seals replaced and the oil pan gasket. It appears that it's still leaking from the axle seals. I've been told that's it's probably the transmission that will need to be replaced.

What would be the most cost effective, rebuild or buy a used one?

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-08-2017 07:24 AM
jabjab is offline Click Here to See the Profile for jabjab Click here to Send jabjab a Private Message Find more posts by jabjab Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
 
bourge73
First Gear

Location: Calgary
What I drive: The Planet Car, Expedition, Maxima
Posts/Day: 0.27
Trader Rating: (35)
User Rating: 94%


quote:

You need a second opinion /shop right now. Or get new friends
if they told you that. What would make you suspect the tranny? How is it driving /shifting regardless of a leaking axle seal?

__________________
A Ferrari is a high maintenance chick, you spend money regardless of what you do with her. You can baby the C63, or slap on all seasons, and you won't be spending anything but yearly maintenance. Of course that's like dating a stripper and refusing to fuck her, which would make you gay.

Originally posted by Rage2

Last edited by bourge73 on 04-08-2017 at 02:10 PM

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-08-2017 02:08 PM
bourge73 is online now Click Here to See the Profile for bourge73 Click here to Send bourge73 a Private Message Find more posts by bourge73 Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Maxx Mazda
First Gear

Location: Calgary
What I drive: Protege 5 Turbo / Ecoboost FX4
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (0)
User Rating: 92%


quote:

Replacing a transmission due to leaky axle seals?? Jesus, I hope you don't actually believe that...

__________________

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-08-2017 02:26 PM
Maxx Mazda is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Maxx Mazda Click here to Send Maxx Mazda a Private Message Find more posts by Maxx Mazda Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
jabjab
Neutral

Location: Calgary
What I drive: TT
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (1)
User Rating: 95%


quote:

When the previous owner had the engine installed I guess the shop had not aligned the tranny right when the axel causing some play when driving and from what I remember the shop said that because of that new axal l seals might keep leaking.

Tranny shifts fine when driving it.

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-08-2017 02:50 PM
jabjab is offline Click Here to See the Profile for jabjab Click here to Send jabjab a Private Message Find more posts by jabjab Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
bourge73
First Gear

Location: Calgary
What I drive: The Planet Car, Expedition, Maxima
Posts/Day: 0.27
Trader Rating: (35)
User Rating: 94%


quote:

Perfect now fix the leaking axle seals and keep driving
Next time don't ask anyone but beyond for mechanical advice

__________________
A Ferrari is a high maintenance chick, you spend money regardless of what you do with her. You can baby the C63, or slap on all seasons, and you won't be spending anything but yearly maintenance. Of course that's like dating a stripper and refusing to fuck her, which would make you gay.

Originally posted by Rage2

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-08-2017 02:52 PM
bourge73 is online now Click Here to See the Profile for bourge73 Click here to Send bourge73 a Private Message Find more posts by bourge73 Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
jabjab
Neutral

Location: Calgary
What I drive: TT
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (1)
User Rating: 95%


quote:

Originally posted by bourge73
Perfect now fix the leaking axle seals and keep driving
Next time don't ask anyone but beyond for mechanical advice



I've already replaced both axle seals 4 months ago and the leak is back. My concern is I don't want to keep replacing them if replacement of the tranny is actually correct

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-08-2017 03:30 PM
jabjab is offline Click Here to See the Profile for jabjab Click here to Send jabjab a Private Message Find more posts by jabjab Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
J-hop
First Gear

Location: calgary
What I drive:
Posts/Day: 0.39
Trader Rating: (0)
User Rating: 100%


quote:

Originally posted by jabjab


I've already replaced both axle seals 4 months ago and the leak is back. My concern is I don't want to keep replacing them if replacement of the tranny is actually correct



Did you try having the axle seals replaced?

I would look for a second opinion preferably from a transmission specialist shop. I'm trying to understand how a misaligned transmission would be damaged beyond repair. Potentially there was a constant stress on the output shaft that has created play as you described and now the output shaft just tears apart the seals.

Explain everything to the second shop and if they conclude the same see what their prices are for rebuild vs replace. One option is picknpull. If yours is a 2001 that makes it a first gen right? There are a couple 99s there right now. That is an option but of course you don't have any gauruntee you'll grab a good trans and it will be a painful job.

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-08-2017 03:49 PM
J-hop is offline Click Here to See the Profile for J-hop Click here to Send J-hop a Private Message Find more posts by J-hop Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
jabjab
Neutral

Location: Calgary
What I drive: TT
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (1)
User Rating: 95%


quote:

Anyone recommend an honest transmission shop? Would the place that replaced the axle seals before warranty any of the work if it fails in less than 6 months? I did go to someone who specializes in honda

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-08-2017 09:58 PM
jabjab is offline Click Here to See the Profile for jabjab Click here to Send jabjab a Private Message Find more posts by jabjab Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
bourge73
First Gear

Location: Calgary
What I drive: The Planet Car, Expedition, Maxima
Posts/Day: 0.27
Trader Rating: (35)
User Rating: 94%


quote:

Pm 'd

__________________
A Ferrari is a high maintenance chick, you spend money regardless of what you do with her. You can baby the C63, or slap on all seasons, and you won't be spending anything but yearly maintenance. Of course that's like dating a stripper and refusing to fuck her, which would make you gay.

Originally posted by Rage2

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-08-2017 10:31 PM
bourge73 is online now Click Here to See the Profile for bourge73 Click here to Send bourge73 a Private Message Find more posts by bourge73 Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
bourge73
First Gear

Location: Calgary
What I drive: The Planet Car, Expedition, Maxima
Posts/Day: 0.27
Trader Rating: (35)
User Rating: 94%


quote:

Edit : pm didn't work sorry for the double post urrrggh
I can help you with a shop if you can contact me tks

__________________
A Ferrari is a high maintenance chick, you spend money regardless of what you do with her. You can baby the C63, or slap on all seasons, and you won't be spending anything but yearly maintenance. Of course that's like dating a stripper and refusing to fuck her, which would make you gay.

Originally posted by Rage2

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-08-2017 10:36 PM
bourge73 is online now Click Here to See the Profile for bourge73 Click here to Send bourge73 a Private Message Find more posts by bourge73 Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
raceman6135
Neutral

Location: Calgary, AB -- Canada
What I drive:
Posts/Day: 0.04
Trader Rating: (0)
User Rating: 100%


quote:

I'm a domestic car guy, and don't know much about this particular Honda transaxle, but I'm wondering if the output shaft bearings or bushings (whichever this vehicle uses) are worn so much that the shaft moves so much the seals can't do their job?

And perhaps on this transaxle, the output shaft bearings/bushings can't be replaced without partially disassembling the transmission?

If that were the case, by the time you disassemble both sides to replace the bearing/bushing, you might as well pull the entire transaxle and replace with a rebuilt one.

The labour charge to drop the transaxle, partially disassemble, replace the bearings, reassemble, and then reinstall the transaxle would be higher than simply R&Ring the entire assembly.

For example, on a GM TH400 transmission, there is an output shaft bushing at the very end of the tailshaft (right behind the seal) that can be replaced rather easily by removing the tailshaft. However, there is also a bushing further inside the case, and it can only be replaced by dropping the transmission and completely removing all the internal components in order to remove the output shaft. If you have to go through all of that work, you might as well replace friction discs and steels, bands, and a few other things while in there.

We certainly need more details about WHY the seals failed before we simply suggest throwing more seals at it.

A second inspection may reveal that the CV shafts are in bad shape where the seal rides (maybe a groove is worn into them, or there are nicks or burrs that damage the seal when the CV shafts are installed), which could also explain why seals that are only a couple of months old are already leaking.

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-09-2017 04:47 PM
raceman6135 is offline Click Here to See the Profile for raceman6135 Click here to Send raceman6135 a Private Message Find more posts by raceman6135 Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
jabjab
Neutral

Location: Calgary
What I drive: TT
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (1)
User Rating: 95%


quote:

Just came back from the shop that did the work. They believe it's tranny fluid leaking where the speed sensor is. It's pretty wet with fluid and gunk so I've sprayed brake cleaner, engine cleaner and then power washed it. Going to drive it for a week and get a better idea of where it is exactly leaking from. I guess I can't by a seal that is around the speed sensor but have to buy the whole sensor if it is leaking from there. Also checked the transmission fluid level is near the top of the max level

Last edited by jabjab on 04-13-2017 at 02:05 AM

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-13-2017 02:03 AM
jabjab is offline Click Here to See the Profile for jabjab Click here to Send jabjab a Private Message Find more posts by jabjab Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Maxx Mazda
First Gear

Location: Calgary
What I drive: Protege 5 Turbo / Ecoboost FX4
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (0)
User Rating: 92%


quote:

It's usually just an O-Ring around most speed sensors. So while you might not be able to get a specific one from Honda without buying the whole sensor, any proper sized $0.02 O ring should do the trick.

__________________

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-13-2017 02:34 AM
Maxx Mazda is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Maxx Mazda Click here to Send Maxx Mazda a Private Message Find more posts by Maxx Mazda Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
ExtraSlow
Third Gear

Location: Food Court Wifi
What I drive: 2010 Recession Fighter LX
Posts/Day: 1.12
Trader Rating: (27)
User Rating: 101%


quote:

Don't spray any more brake cleaner there. That shit is bad for rubber.

__________________
Make fun of me in the 2017 Tow Rig thread!

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-13-2017 02:56 AM
ExtraSlow is offline Click Here to See the Profile for ExtraSlow Click here to Send ExtraSlow a Private Message Find more posts by ExtraSlow Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
jabjab
Neutral

Location: Calgary
What I drive: TT
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (1)
User Rating: 95%


quote:

Originally posted by Maxx Mazda
It's usually just an O-Ring around most speed sensors. So while you might not be able to get a specific one from Honda without buying the whole sensor, any proper sized $0.02 O ring should do the trick.



I wonder why they didn't suggest this?

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-13-2017 03:05 AM
jabjab is offline Click Here to See the Profile for jabjab Click here to Send jabjab a Private Message Find more posts by jabjab Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
carson blocks
First Gear

Location: Calgary
What I drive: 1917 Model T, VW Baja, 2016 Longhorn
Posts/Day: 0.14
Trader Rating: (2)
User Rating: 103%


quote:

Originally posted by jabjab


I wonder why they didn't suggest this?



Because they don't make as much money replacing a 25 cent o-ring. Plus, there's always the slight chance that it doesn't work or they pick the wrong one. Factory part is a safer bet for them, makes them more money, and they're not paying the bill, you are.

Time to learn to turn wrenches?

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-13-2017 04:57 AM
carson blocks is offline Click Here to See the Profile for carson blocks Click here to Send carson blocks a Private Message Find more posts by carson blocks Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
jabjab
Neutral

Location: Calgary
What I drive: TT
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (1)
User Rating: 95%


quote:

It almost makes sense to take out my speed sensor, go take the old O ring to a parts store and get the same one. Put it back and watch to see if its leaking again.

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-13-2017 02:20 PM
jabjab is offline Click Here to See the Profile for jabjab Click here to Send jabjab a Private Message Find more posts by jabjab Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
jabjab
Neutral

Location: Calgary
What I drive: TT
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (1)
User Rating: 95%


quote:

Originally posted by Maxx Mazda
It's usually just an O-Ring around most speed sensors. So while you might not be able to get a specific one from Honda without buying the whole sensor, any proper sized $0.02 O ring should do the trick.



Where is a good place that carries a vast array of O rings?

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-13-2017 02:22 PM
jabjab is offline Click Here to See the Profile for jabjab Click here to Send jabjab a Private Message Find more posts by jabjab Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Maxx Mazda
First Gear

Location: Calgary
What I drive: Protege 5 Turbo / Ecoboost FX4
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (0)
User Rating: 92%


quote:

Anywhere. Shit, I got a 250 count pack of various sizes from Princess Auto for like $5

__________________

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-13-2017 02:23 PM
Maxx Mazda is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Maxx Mazda Click here to Send Maxx Mazda a Private Message Find more posts by Maxx Mazda Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
mzdspd
Neutral

Location: Edmonton
What I drive: LNF
Posts/Day: 0.18
Trader Rating: (0)
User Rating: 100%


quote:

Originally posted by jabjab


Where is a good place that carries a vast array of O rings?



Hi-tech seals

Report this post | IP: Logged

Old Post 04-13-2017 04:10 PM
mzdspd is offline Click Here to See the Profile for mzdspd Click here to Send mzdspd a Private Message Find more posts by mzdspd Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
The time now is 08:18 PM (GMT) Post New Thread   
 
Last Thread   Next Thread
Beyond.ca - Car Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.3.9 Beyond.ca - Car Forums > Car Forums > General Car/Bike Talk > Replace or rebuild transmission?



Show Printable Version | Email this Page | Subscribe to this Thread


Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
 

Google
 
Web beyond.ca

Terms of Use - Contact Us - Advertising Info - Archives - Car Blog

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.3.9
Copyright ©2009 Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.

Bringing Car Enthusiasts together in discussion on our car forums

Page Statistics : Page generated in 0.09533191 seconds (73.79% PHP - 26.21% MySQL) with 41 queries.