PDA

View Full Version : Crude Train Derailments



dirtsniffer
02-17-2015, 09:57 AM
Train derailment in West Virginia causing a large fire. Thankfully no casualties. A waterway was effected.

http://i59.tinypic.com/2n16vic.jpg



One or two train cars plunged into the Kanawha River, and "a couple are burning," said Robert Jelacic, night shift manager of the West Virginia Department of Homeland Security and Emergency Management. There were no injuries or deaths, he said.

The company issued a news release saying one person was being treated for potential inhalation issues, but no other injuries were reported.

A one-kilometre-wide area around the derailment was being evacuated after a house caught fire because of the accident, Lawrence Messina, spokesman for the West Virginia Department of Military Affairs and Public Safety, told Reuters.

Messina said CSX had confirmed the train's only cargo was crude oil. Heavy snow and frigid temperatures were hindering efforts to deal with the incident, Jelacic said. A CSX spokesman did not immediately reply to messages seeking comment.

The train derailed at 1:20 p.m. ET about 54 kilometres southeast of Charleston, the state capital, according to Fayette
County 911 Coordinator James Bennett.

Crews from the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection and numerous fire departments responded to the scene, Messina said.

WOWK television reported that the nearby towns of Adena Village and Boomer Bottom were being evacuated.

It was not immediately clear where the train was heading, where its cargo originated or whose oil it was carrying. The
crash occurred less than 320 kilometres west of Lynchburg, Virginia, where another CSX train bound for an East Coast oil terminal run by Plains All American Pipelines derailed and erupted in flames last April

Local websites showed images of large flames and a thick plume of black smoke near a partly frozen river, with a number of houses nearby.

The latest incident comes just two days after Canadian National Railways train from Alberta's oil sands derailed in a remote wooded area of northern Ontario. CN said 29 of 100 cars were involved and seven caught fire. No injuries were reported, but the cars were still on fire on Monday.

A boom in oil shipments by rail and a spate of derailments across North America have put heightened focus on rail safety. In 2013, 47 people were killed in the Quebec town of Lac-Mégantic after a train carrying crude oil derailed and exploded.

The latest incidents will likely refocus attention on U.S. and Canadian regulators' efforts to improve the safety of such shipments, which have spurred concerns over both the flammability of very light oil from the North Dakota Bakken shale as well as the flawed design of older tank cars.

The U.S. Transportation Department has submitted a proposal to the White House to require adding an extra 1/8th inch of steel to most existing oil train tank shells, while new models would have the thicker hull installed on the factory floor.

It was unclear what kind of tank cars were involved in the derailment on Monday.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/west-virginia-oil-train-derails-and-burns-towns-evacuated-1.2959296

ExtraSlow
02-17-2015, 10:14 AM
It will be interesting to see the regulatory and political fallout from this. Railways are an inefficient way to move crude, but they are more expedient than waiting for politicians to approve pipelines.

I think the most rations response to these incidents would be to get as many new pipelines built as possible. However, this could have the opposite effect. These graphic images could harden the resolve for activists and communities to keep these dangerous products from being shipped by any means.

How will this play out? I have no idea. :dunno:

freshprince1
02-17-2015, 10:49 AM
Drove past a derailment over the weekend right at Frank Slide. Not sure what was in the tankers, but they were the black cylindrical ones. Seems to be a lot of these going on these days?

Feruk
02-17-2015, 12:16 PM
There was a derailment in Ontario with associated crude spill on the weekend as well.

Another win for Greenpeace!

EM2FTL
02-17-2015, 12:29 PM
Not too surprising, but with a reduced WCS spread rail becomes far less viable up here. Seems to have peaked for now:

http://business.financialpost.com/2015/02/09/oil-by-rail-economics-suffers-amid-narrowing-spreads/?__lsa=58c4-70b1


"Right now, there are very few movements of crude by rail coming from Western Canada into the Gulf Coast, because it just does not make sense economically," said Bridget Hunsucker, analyst at Genscape, which tracks weekly oil carloads across North America.

Before oil prices sank, Canadian producers shipped oil on rail to fetch much higher West Texas Intermediate oil prices on the U.S. Gulf Coast than they could at the Hardisty terminal in Alberta. The business made sense even after taking into account transportation costs as high as $21 per barrel of oil on rail, compared to $7 via pipeline.

In addition, transporting much-needed diluents back from Houston to Alberta transformed the oil-by-rail business into a roaring growth segment for midstream and rail companies.

But that business model is eroding. While crude prices fell 48% last year, that's not precisely what triggered the collapse - it's the narrowing of Western Canada Select's discount to under $13 compared to WTI and Mexican Maya that's derailing the business.

Pipeline utilization in the Bakken shot up to 80% by the end of December, compared to 50% at the start of 2014, as producers jumped from rail to pipeline to preserve margins.

"That would be similar for WCS, and as that narrows, people gravitate to pipe if they can," says Jenna Delaney, an analyst with Bentek Energy, a forecasting unit of Platts. "Of course those barrels - if they need to move - are still going to jump on rail. It just won't be an economic move," Ms. Delaney said.

Oil-by-rail picked up steam in recent years, as flagship pipelines such as Keystone XL and Northern Gateway became mired in controversy. But after growing ten-fold between 2012 to 2013, volumes seemed to plateau last year.



Crazy to see how much expansion there has been in the US in the past 10 years:

https://www.aar.org/Charts/Commodity/energy_independence_chart.jpg