PDA

View Full Version : Renewing mortgage before term is up.



16hypen3sp
08-12-2017, 04:42 PM
Hey all,

I received a phone call from a mortgage specialist from my local bank (well, credit union). This bank is where my mortgage has been from the get-go. She told me that they are offering mortgage owners an early renewal because the prime lending rates are climbing. My mortgage is up for renewal in 10 months. I had locked in at 5 years previously for 2.99%. She said if I renewed now, it would be the same rate. The only reason to renew now is mitigate any further lending rate increases down the road.

This is my first mortgage and first time renewing. I don't know much about it.

It sounds like I should take the offer and renew now instead of risk it and see a further rate increase.

Any advice?

Thanks.

suntan
08-12-2017, 04:48 PM
Most places can't hold for more than 120 days, best rate right now is 2.56% on a 5 five year.

Question is do you think rates will go 40 basis points in six months?

ExtraSlow
08-12-2017, 10:57 PM
They want you to renew before your term is up and not shop around. This is pretty common practice. Often you can negotiate that rate a little more, particularly if you have a quote from another lender for lower.

People hate to change lenders, it's a hassle, but you should at least pretend to be shopping around when negotiating your renewal rate.

BokCh0y
08-13-2017, 10:58 AM
Some places like first calgary is offering a promo rate at 2.79%.

tonytiger55
08-13-2017, 11:23 AM
They want to retain your business and not have you shop around. Negotiate as stated above.

That being said, if you do shop around you may have to pay fee's for a new mortgage which may make it unviable.

suntan
08-13-2017, 12:26 PM
They want to retain your business and not have you shop around. Negotiate as stated above.

That being said, if you do shop around you may have to pay fee's for a new mortgage which may make it unviable.

He's renewing, the expectation is that all fees are covered by the new lender.

thinmyster
08-13-2017, 03:14 PM
I'm due in about 10months also (with street-capital). Haven't heard shit :zzz:

16hypen3sp
08-13-2017, 03:30 PM
Ok guys. Thanks for the replies. I'll see if they move on the rate or not.

ExtraSlow
08-13-2017, 05:18 PM
Most lenders that want to earn your business away from your current one will cover all fees. That's pretty common.

tonytiger55
08-13-2017, 09:00 PM
That was my thoughts too.
It did not work with my friend who had their mortgage with BMO. New lenders would not cover it, even our broker suggested staying with the current lender. :dunno:

Xtrema
08-14-2017, 03:12 PM
Most places can't hold for more than 120 days, best rate right now is 2.56% on a 5 five year.

Question is do you think rates will go 40 basis points in six months?

Listen to this man, there is no point renewing early if that's what you most likely get in 6 months anyway.

I just got 2.64 2 weeks ago from RBC. Given it's before the news of rate hike but renewal is also less risky then a new loan. If they are a credit union, they should be able to beat RBC. So I would say close to or under 2.6% before you bite.

Buster
08-14-2017, 03:43 PM
you sure you want to go fixed?

Xtrema
08-14-2017, 06:17 PM
you sure you want to go fixed?

You think fixed will go lower in the future? Or do you think rates hikes are fake?

HiTempguy1
08-15-2017, 10:43 AM
You think fixed will go lower in the future? Or do you think rates hikes are fake?

Well, you can still get variable for 2% so you tell me? For the past two decades, variable has basically always worked out to be cheaper. I locked in because I am risk averse, but I'm pretty happy with my 2.54% for 5 years now.

suntan
08-15-2017, 02:31 PM
Well, you can still get variable for 2% so you tell me? For the past two decades, variable has basically always worked out to be cheaper. I locked in because I am risk averse, but I'm pretty happy with my 2.54% for 5 years now.

The problem is where are rates going to be in six months.

Variable is even worse for holding, usually they're only 60 days. So it's great and all that you can get it right now, but what about in 8 months?

Buster
08-15-2017, 03:25 PM
A fixed rate is a bet against the traders at the bank that rates will not go up past XX.XX%.

Do you think that the traders at the bank that are setting these rates know LESS than you do about where rates will go? It's these peoples' job to determine what the probability is of a profit based on a particular rate at retail. If rates had a higher likelihood of going up (as is suggested here), then you would see an even steeper spread between variable and fixed rates.

Furthermore, the fixed rates are determined not by one trader at one bank, but the market determines the fixed rates. So the fixed rate you're looking at is actually the blended consensus of the predictions by all of the smart traders at all of the retail banks across the country (and world really) about what rates will look like.

And yet, we think that we can determine, objectively, that they are wrong? Sometimes they are. But it's relatively rare, and your chances by luck of hitting one of those times just when you happen to be renewing your mortgage is quite unlikely.

jutes
08-16-2017, 12:19 PM
Regarding this, I still have about 2 years left before my current 5 year term is up. I'd like to put down a substantial amount to lower my payments, because if I just put this money down on the mgt it will decrease length of the amortisation, not monthly payments. Would there be any penalties if I refinance early or does it depend on my lender - TD?

Xtrema
08-16-2017, 12:58 PM
Regarding this, I still have about 2 years left before my current 5 year term is up. I'd like to put down a substantial amount to lower my payments, because if I just put this money down on the mgt it will decrease length of the amortisation, not monthly payments. Would there be any penalties if I refinance early or does it depend on my lender - TD?

Check your contract. There are clauses about how much principle pay down you are allowed per year, so while payment doesn't change, amortization decreases and more of your payment will go toward principle. As for refinances early, it really depends variable or fixed. Variable to fixed usually is kosher without extra charges (because you are paying 0.5% more = more profit for the bank). Fixed to fixed usually has some penalty involved.


A fixed rate is a bet against the traders at the bank that rates will not go up past XX.XX%.

Do you think that the traders at the bank that are setting these rates know LESS than you do about where rates will go? It's these peoples' job to determine what the probability is of a profit based on a particular rate at retail. If rates had a higher likelihood of going up (as is suggested here), then you would see an even steeper spread between variable and fixed rates.

Furthermore, the fixed rates are determined not by one trader at one bank, but the market determines the fixed rates. So the fixed rate you're looking at is actually the blended consensus of the predictions by all of the smart traders at all of the retail banks across the country (and world really) about what rates will look like.

And yet, we think that we can determine, objectively, that they are wrong? Sometimes they are. But it's relatively rare, and your chances by luck of hitting one of those times just when you happen to be renewing your mortgage is quite unlikely.


End of the day, variable is 2%, fixed was 2.5/2.6%. All you are betting on is that Bank of Canada won't raise 0.5% over the next 2 years. If they do, fixed wins. If they don't variable wins.

Buster
08-16-2017, 01:13 PM
End of the day, variable is 2%, fixed was 2.5/2.6%. All you are betting on is that Bank of Canada won't raise 0.5% over the next 2 years. If they do, fixed wins. If they don't variable wins.

Not quite. How early they raise matters a great deal in terms of who wins in the bet/trade. For every month that you pay the lower interest you are accumulating capital (which then has a time-value all its own). For you to lose on going variable, the bank must raise rates PAST the current fixed rate, and by a significant amount. Let's say the BoC raises rates 50 basis points over the next to years, at the end of that period, you have saved the interest in the meantime. So for the next two years, they must raise rates PAST where the existing fixed rate is in order to be able to "catch up" and eclipse your cost savings. So going fixed isn't a bet that they will raise 50 basis points within your term, it's probably a bet that they will raise them 100 basis points or more.

More to the point: the vast majority of experts (ie people with huge amount of capital and a lot at stake), all seem to agree that this is somewhat to highly improbable. You going fixed is essentially the admission that you think they are wrong. They are rarely wrong. Their job is to make you feel more secure by purchasing what is essentially an insurance policy. A very expensive insurance policy.

realazy
08-16-2017, 01:15 PM
End of the day, variable is 2%, fixed was 2.5/2.6%. All you are betting on is that Bank of Canada won't raise 0.5% over the next 2 years. If they do, fixed wins. If they don't variable wins.



However, if you get 1 year before they raise it 0.5%. You're already ahead because you saved that 0.5% for that 1 year. Then if variable at that time is at 2.5% you're still only even going forward.

The BOC is raising rates 0.25% at a time. You'll still be ahead with variable unless they raise it 1% in one year and continue to do so afterwards.

The market consensus is that they have to tread carefully on rate increases and the likelihood of a rapid rate increase is low.

ExtraSlow
08-16-2017, 01:31 PM
Agree that fixed mortgages are a form of insurance policy. However for mid to lower income people or first time homeowners without significant additional savings, it can make a lot of sense.

realazy
08-16-2017, 01:42 PM
Agree that fixed mortgages are a form of insurance policy. However for mid to lower income people or first time homeowners without significant additional savings, it can make a lot of sense.

That's a funny way to look at it. For lower income people, they usually worry about the cash flow, and a lower variable rate mortgage will give you a lower monthly payment. If the rate goes up, you just end up paying less principle, which most lower income people don't seem to care about, judging by the 96 month auto loans.

Note the difference between variable rate and adjustable rate.

msommers
08-21-2017, 10:13 PM
I've gotta renew in about a year. What's the best rates people have found for 5 year fix/variable?

Xtrema
08-22-2017, 09:12 AM
I've gotta renew in about a year. What's the best rates people have found for 5 year fix/variable?

Fixed: 2.64
Variable 1.94

If you got a year, there is another 8 months before you can lock it down. Rate hike still likely in that period but cooled a bit from latest data.

Twin_Cam_Turbo
08-22-2017, 12:29 PM
I talked to my bank about renewing my fixed 5 year early (16 months left) earlier this summer. They calculated it out for me and showed it would actually cost me $4k more to break and renew early even with the drop from 3.39 to 2.79%. It will depend on your contract and what they will charge you to do it.

Overall I haven't been very happy with my bank the first time around and will be shopping around for sure next year when it's almost time to renew.

Xtrema
08-22-2017, 07:33 PM
I talked to my bank about renewing my fixed 5 year early (16 months left) earlier this summer. They calculated it out for me and showed it would actually cost me $4k more to break and renew early even with the drop from 3.39 to 2.79%. It will depend on your contract and what they will charge you to do it.

Overall I haven't been very happy with my bank the first time around and will be shopping around for sure next year when it's almost time to renew.

Fixed 3.39% in 2013 was pretty good, not great. And variable vs fixed is harder to decide since if I recall, oil has not crash yet and it could go either way.

Yeah, getting out of fixed usually means penalty and you are hoping that you won't get screwed when term is up or near. At current pace, I would expect you will get the same rate when you renew.

Twin_Cam_Turbo
08-23-2017, 10:11 AM
Fixed 3.39% in 2013 was pretty good, not great. And variable vs fixed is harder to decide since if I recall, oil has not crash yet and it could go either way.

Yeah, getting out of fixed usually means penalty and you are hoping that you won't get screwed when term is up or near. At current pace, I would expect you will get the same rate when you renew.

Yeah my main problem with them was they were late forwarding the money to the builder and I was charged $1000 in interest because of that. Everything was well documented of the date I gave them etc months ahead of time and they refused to accept responsibility and reimburse me. So I made it my goal to pay the absolute maximum I could without fees every year so they would make as little interest off of me as possible because I'm salty.

88CRX
08-23-2017, 10:29 AM
Are the quarterly 0.25% rate hikes no longer likely?

Good news if that's the case but most of the online articles I've read were expecting rates to continue an upward trend of the coming year(s)... but who really knows, right?

jwslam
08-23-2017, 10:36 AM
Yeah my main problem with them was they were late forwarding the money to the builder and I was charged $1000 in interest because of that. Everything was well documented of the date I gave them etc months ahead of time and they refused to accept responsibility and reimburse me. So I made it my goal to pay the absolute maximum I could without fees every year so they would make as little interest off of me as possible because I'm salty.
Umm... mortgage interest is front loaded anyways, so unless you had intentions of renewing with them, your plan really doesn't work as well as you think.

http://budgeting.thenest.com/frontloaded-mortgage-work-24047.html

Twin_Cam_Turbo
08-23-2017, 10:39 AM
Umm... mortgage interest is front loaded anyways, so unless you had intentions of renewing with them, your plan really doesn't work as well as you think.

http://budgeting.thenest.com/frontloaded-mortgage-work-24047.html

Lump sum payments go directly to the principal, which is why I make the maximum lump sum payments every time.

jwslam
08-23-2017, 12:09 PM
Lump sum payments go directly to the principal, which is why I make the maximum lump sum payments every time.
Yes I know that.
But I'm fairly sure that for the duration of your 3 year term, the amount of each payment dedicated to interest does not change..

Buster
08-23-2017, 12:16 PM
Umm... mortgage interest is front loaded anyways, so unless you had intentions of renewing with them, your plan really doesn't work as well as you think.

http://budgeting.thenest.com/frontloaded-mortgage-work-24047.html


Yes I know that.
But I'm fairly sure that for the duration of your 3 year term, the amount of each payment dedicated to interest does not change..

Actually, this is not true.

When you put a lump sum down, your total interest obligation goes down, and the amount of interest you are paying in your blended payment goes down. Paydowns hurt the profitability of the lender.

Twin_Cam_Turbo
08-23-2017, 01:01 PM
Lump sum payments go directly to the principal, which is why I make the maximum lump sum payments every time.

Yeah that's definitely not true. You can see the difference even with an online mortgage payment calculator when you add lump sum payments. I've added 10% per year to my regular payments too and it all goes towards the principal, meaning I pay less interest by the end and shortens the time left until the balance is zero, assuming I don't stop paying and take a break or something.

realazy
08-23-2017, 01:22 PM
Not sure how your lender does it, but my lender shows the interest accrued on the principle remaining since the last payment. Each payment consists of the interest accrued since the last payment and the principle. The payment amount is calculated based on the amortized term and interest rate and is fixed for the term. The difference between the payment amount and accrued interest goes towards principle.

Twin_Cam_Turbo
08-23-2017, 01:32 PM
Not sure how your lender does it, but my lender shows the interest accrued on the principle remaining since the last payment. Each payment consists of the interest accrued since the last payment and the principle. The payment amount is calculated based on the amortized term and interest rate and is fixed for the term. The difference between the payment amount and accrued interest goes towards principle.

Yep mine shows the same, and the interest has definitely dropped since the start. I was about 55% interest 45% principle at the start and I'm sitting around 32% interest and 68% principle now.

TurboMedic
08-23-2017, 02:31 PM
Fixed 3.39% in 2013 was pretty good, not great. And variable vs fixed is harder to decide since if I recall, oil has not crash yet and it could go either way.

Yeah, getting out of fixed usually means penalty and you are hoping that you won't get screwed when term is up or near. At current pace, I would expect you will get the same rate when you renew.

3.39 in 2013 wasn't great at all, we got 2.89 on the first offer with our broker...I'd definitely like to stay there or cheaper as they did drop slightly.....I'm in the same boat as a bunch here, mortgage is up in May and trying to decide on the tactic to come out ahead! I also had variable in the past and did like it, but that was when I was able to get prime - 0.55 or prime -1 I can't recall, but I had a rate of 1.5-2% IIRC, but that was a long time ago