PDA

View Full Version : Limited Slip Diff



Weapon_R
10-16-2002, 10:28 PM
Got a cool deal on an LSD for my ride, wondering if its worth the $250 to get one? Is the acceleration noticable? Does it help in winter on ice? Any suggestions would be appreciated!

GTS Jeff
10-16-2002, 10:47 PM
definitely go for it! an lsd on a fwd will get rid of a lot of understeer! it will help a bit in the winter too.

Weapon_R
10-16-2002, 10:48 PM
Think its a good deal too?

Define understeer please, and how this will help.

ecstasyracer
10-16-2002, 10:56 PM
Understeer is when you are cornering hard and your car wants to go more strait instead of keeping tight on the corner like you want it to. The lsd will not let your inside front tire spin if you are cornering really hard and get on the throttle.

I'd say definetly go for it, but don't forget the cost of getting it installed too.

Weapon_R
10-16-2002, 11:17 PM
Cost of installation isn't that big of a deal - my friend and I will tear it apart and install it. I've read a bit about installation and its not hard to do.

szw
10-16-2002, 11:21 PM
250 bucks seem really cheap

I just tested mine last week on an icy ramp.

Came to a stop and accelerated quickly, those helical gears whine like a bitch! But a few seconds later I was moving...don't know how it would have been without the diff..but it is good to have.

Is it used? and what kind of diff?

redline_13000
10-16-2002, 11:38 PM
take it...u will feel the biggest difference...i used to have a jimmy without a locking diff...that thing would spin if u breathed on the pedal..now my new one has one...very hard to do a burnout...great on ice

GTS Jeff
10-16-2002, 11:42 PM
heh and u will also have insane launches with an lsd

Weapon_R
10-16-2002, 11:45 PM
So launches will greatly improve? I always have a problem with too much wheelspin, especially when it gets really cold, and i'm hoping this will help.

How do these things work? Do they always launch using two wheels, or does it "sense" that one is spinning and apply the second? If it "senses", then wouldn't a person get some wheelspin anyways? Or does it do it instantaneously.

ancient
10-16-2002, 11:50 PM
I've heard with some of the guys who put in Qualife (sp?) LSD trannys into their ludes, and didn't notice any difference in their times other than they could drop the clutch from a higher RPM without getting as much wheelspin.... ALL tho it did result in a faster 1/4 mile, due to the fact they can drop in from a higher rpm...


Other than that they said if they dropped from say 3000 with both their lsd and normal tranny it was the same.


I dunno I could search for more definate info but im lazy...


Im probably just reading through peoples bs, so please correct me if im way off here.

buh_buh
10-16-2002, 11:57 PM
uh... where and what kind of LSD are you finding for $250? Last time I checked they were around $1000+

Weapon_R
10-17-2002, 12:08 AM
Originally posted by buh_buh
uh... where and what kind of LSD are you finding for $250? Last time I checked they were around $1000+

:)


Sometimes, if you look hard enough, and are lucky, you will find good deals.

redline
10-17-2002, 07:54 AM
so what kind is it?

It depends on the type of LSD as to the results for launching and cornering. Some are more aggressive then others.

I hope it is not a phatom grip.... those things suck ass...

Voodoo Child
10-17-2002, 09:17 AM
Weapon_R,
Don't even question the fact of NOT having an LSD. All Type R's come with them stock and let me tell you, you can pull hard as hell into a corner and not have to worry about it.
Also, at the track I was launching between 6500 and 7000 rpm.
I had some wheel hop, but significantly less than a car without an LSD.
Also if you ever saw XES at the track without his you would have seen why you NEED one.

For $250 buy it, but make sure it's reliable. You do not want to put the thing in and have it shatter on you the next day.

My 2 cents.

VC:thumbsup:

T5_X
10-17-2002, 10:16 AM
From what I've heard, LSD can be sketchy in winter. It will help out with launches, but around corners, it can be detrimental to handling. Think about it, in a RWD when your rear end starts to shoot out and you drift, its easy to correct with an open diff. Only one wheel is spinning, the other one resists the drift so your rear end doesn't fly out, the one spinning has little "lateral" grip with the road. Now on a LSD, if both tires are spinning, you lose lateral grip and the rear end shoots out quick. I guess if you really know what you're doing, you can correct easily with either, but not to many ppl are pro drivers :)
I don't know about FWD, it seems once you lose traction on your front wheels, you wouldn't hit the trottle cause if you do there's even less of a chance to correct and regain control. If you did hit the trottle though with LSD, i'd imagine you'd slide right off the road faster due to heavy understeer w/ no traction, at least the outside wheel might have a chance of pulling you around with an open diff once you've slowed the car enough. Not much experience with front drive yet so I'm not too sure.

GTS Jeff
10-17-2002, 10:25 AM
Originally posted by Ranger_X31
I don't know about FWD, it seems once you lose traction on your front wheels, you wouldn't hit the trottle cause if you do there's even less of a chance to correct and regain control. If you did hit the trottle though with LSD, i'd imagine you'd slide right off the road faster due to heavy understeer w/ no traction, at least the outside wheel might have a chance of pulling you around with an open diff once you've slowed the car enough. Not much experience with front drive yet so I'm not too sure. actually, its the opposite of what u said.

on a fwd, u normally encounter understeer on low traction surfaces. with an open differential, the engines power is sent to the with the least resistance, which in a corner would be the inside wheel, since there is the least force being applied on it. a spinning inside wheel wont turn the car.

an lsd will send the engines power to the outside wheel, which is what will turn the car.

T5_X
10-17-2002, 10:38 AM
Originally posted by Jeff TYPE R
actually, its the opposite of what u said.

on a fwd, u normally encounter understeer on low traction surfaces. with an open differential, the engines power is sent to the with the least resistance, which in a corner would be the inside wheel, since there is the least force being applied on it. a spinning inside wheel wont turn the car.

an lsd will send the engines power to the outside wheel, which is what will turn the car.

I know that, what I'm saying is that in an open diff, both wheels are spinning, correct? if you're inexperienced and go WOT around a corner, a wheel spinning slides sideways easier than a wheel not spinning, so in an open diff, that outside wheel (which is not spinning) may slow you down enough to pull you safely out of the turn. Once again though, with a pro driver, the LSD will probably work as good if not better, cause they know when to lay on the trottle and pull out of the turn.

GTS Jeff
10-17-2002, 11:03 AM
Originally posted by Ranger_X31


I know that, what I'm saying is that in an open diff, both wheels are spinning, correct? if you're inexperienced and go WOT around a corner, a wheel spinning slides sideways easier than a wheel not spinning, so in an open diff, that outside wheel (which is not spinning) may slow you down enough to pull you safely out of the turn. Once again though, with a pro driver, the LSD will probably work as good if not better, cause they know when to lay on the trottle and pull out of the turn. nope. in an open diff, only the inside wheel will spin. an lsd will "lock" and make BOTH wheels spin.

and an un-powered outside wheel wont slow anything down :) a car only slows down when u put the brakes on :thumbsup:

Weapon_R
10-17-2002, 01:29 PM
Originally posted by redline
so what kind is it?

It depends on the type of LSD as to the results for launching and cornering. Some are more aggressive then others.

I hope it is not a phatom grip.... those things suck ass...

I'll let you know when I go and check it out. I think its an aftermarket one, but an LSD nonetheless.

btw - what is a phatom grip? An LSD? Whats so bad about it? Isn't an lsd an lsd?

szw
10-17-2002, 01:46 PM
There was a favourable article about the phanton grip in a recent SCC (it was on a 200sx 1.6L)

I dont' think its an actual LSD, but mimics one. Not exactly sure.

There are different types of differentials (helical gears, viscous lsd (hlsd and vlsd respectively)).

GTS Jeff
10-17-2002, 02:20 PM
Originally posted by Weapon_R


I'll let you know when I go and check it out. I think its an aftermarket one, but an LSD nonetheless.

btw - what is a phatom grip? An LSD? Whats so bad about it? Isn't an lsd an lsd? theres different kinds of lsds. some use gears, some use clutchpacks, some use hydraulics....theres also different settings...like how much the lsd locks under what conditions etc..

Ben
10-17-2002, 02:54 PM
LSD Ownz, the benefits outweigh the drawbacks, so thats that

GTS Jeff
10-17-2002, 03:34 PM
Originally posted by Benny
LSD Ownz, the benefits outweigh the drawbacks, so thats that heh yea, get ben to give u a ride thru the mud fields around my house and u will see how awesome fwd lsds are!

T5_X
10-17-2002, 03:47 PM
Originally posted by Jeff TYPE R
nope. in an open diff, only the inside wheel will spin. an lsd will "lock" and make BOTH wheels spin.

and an un-powered outside wheel wont slow anything down :) a car only slows down when u put the brakes on :thumbsup:

whoops, made an error in that last post, the first time I said open diff, I meant to say LSD.

And an Un-powered wheel WILL slow you down when drifting laterally or losing traction in understeer. Why is it so easy to drift in RWD when you're giving it throttle? Its cause when the wheels are spinning, they have less friction to stop the car from drifting sideways, if you're not giving it throttle at all then it won't drift near as easily. My point is that in many situations, the open diff is just safer and more predictable for all but advanced drivers. I didn't get an LSD on my truck for this reason. It's hard enough to handle as it is, and in an emergency situation, the open diff helps.

GTS Jeff
10-17-2002, 10:16 PM
Originally posted by Ranger_X31


whoops, made an error in that last post, the first time I said open diff, I meant to say LSD.

And an Un-powered wheel WILL slow you down when drifting laterally or losing traction in understeer. Why is it so easy to drift in RWD when you're giving it throttle? Its cause when the wheels are spinning, they have less friction to stop the car from drifting sideways, if you're not giving it throttle at all then it won't drift near as easily. My point is that in many situations, the open diff is just safer and more predictable for all but advanced drivers. I didn't get an LSD on my truck for this reason. It's hard enough to handle as it is, and in an emergency situation, the open diff helps. an lsd on a fwd is way different than on a rwd.

now i think u are confusing a spinning wheel with an unpowered wheel. an "unpowered wheel" is still free-spinning, but just not receiving power from the engine. a "spinning wheel" as we're using it now, is a free-spinning wheel that is receiving power from the engine. in BOTH cases, the wheel is still free spinning. when a wheel is free spinning, it does not aid in slowing a car down. pretty much NOTHING will aid a car in slowing down in snow (other than good tires). what an LSD can do that an open differential cant is pull the car in the direction that the driver is steering, given that the throttle is open.

just think, in a turn, the outside wheel has more grip than the inside wheel (due to body roll) so if the engines power were to be directed at that wheel, then the car has a better chance of turning than if the power were to be sent to the inside wheel (which is what happens with an open diff)

Dope Dealer
10-17-2002, 10:17 PM
:werd:

Ditto on what Jeff said! :thumbsup: