Solid reference
Printable View
This is a market I know well, with three kids.
IF you want a usable third row, then the mid-size SUVs are pretty much out. There is a small subniche of what I would call large crossovers out there which have more room in the third row and are slightly larger than the midsize category. The Mercedes GL/GLS is in that category, but I would not recommend it if you are on a budget. Expensive cars to keep on the road. They are also a bit less practical for kids due to interior materials and less functional access to the third row. We ended up with an Atlas, after some complaining from the wife about the brand. It's been good so far.
You can also look at used current gen Chevy Traverse.
We actually went with captain chairs in the Atlas, so one kid always is in the back row, but it has worked out. Makes 3rd row access for adults a lot better and makes the 3rd row feel much roomier.
We were also in the same market and agree that mid size SUV's are pretty much out. While the atlas had the most room (imo) out off all the mid-sizers we looked at, it didn't have enough power for my liking. In the end we went with a non-xl suburban which had the space we wanted plus the power to pull a boat.
That said, i really wanted a minivan. Mostly because i am cheap and they are the ultimate family hauler (and i didn't have to regularly drive it lol). The Pacifica is the gold standard here that looks quite sharp and has some pretty interesting offerings.
The Atlas is very compromised. It's short on power, and the suspension does not feel modern in any way. It feels like what it is - essentially a large version of one of VWs two generic platforms. On the plus side, it is almost as functional as a minivan with AWD and ground clearance for the winter. It' interior is reasonably nice, and durable enough to combat the kids. We don't tow, so getting a body on frame SUV doesn't make sense for us, and the full size SUVs are too much of a pain.
The list was short.
Attachment 97743
or
Attachment 97744
or GTFO
Huderite van?
My parents had an Astro in the 90’s. That thing was the tits.
Do you need to move all those midgets AND stuff? All the 3 row Midsize SUV’s will have no space behind the 3rd row. The only thing that will hold 7 people and gear are full-size SUV’s and mini-vans. 90’s GM Suburban wins.
Even an odyssey doesn’t have that much room when the third row is up. Just saying. Midgets have a lot of garbage.
Suburban wins.
This is correct. A bit of cargo room behind the back seats is critical, which is why I'm surprised there aren't more than a handful of large crossovers on the market. Which again left us with the Atlas.
Attachment 97756
Atlas is good geometry. Never owned or driven one.
Mostly midgets only, very little stuff. If vehicle ever used for stuff too, midgets are all in 2nd row, and 3rd row folded down to carry the stuff. Midgets+friends=no stuff being hauled, which is ok.
The Atlas looks nice, but its not in the under $30K price range.
Confirmed on the big body GM stuff. We’ve got 3 kids under 6 and tow a boat so it was Suburban/Denali XL/Escalade ESV or two vehicles for every trip
Wife likes our Expedition Max Limited, except for it being a boat to park
They're hard to find with the middle row bench seat though as usually the max limiteds and max platinums came with captains chairs
I don't know if you'll find an Ecoboost aged one in the 30k price range and if gas mileage really is a consideration then the V8 is a no-no (i think we've been averaging about 19-20l/100km) but since she doesn't drive much it's not bothering us