This is going to sound dumb because it probably is.
I got some winters on rims from Kal Tire for my BMW (F25). Dude insisted that I need a new set of lug bolts. I gave in to pressure and purchased them.
Now I realized that it's an M14 x 1.25 x 27mm. This unit here: https://goo.gl/VePdgu
Isn't that the same size as the OEM lugs? Why can't I use the OEM lugs?