Verns IMO has always been nasty... and I do prefer a "deep dish" to most Naples style thin crusts or hand tossed

for me #1 is Verona's, specifically the one at Gulf Canada Square when the owner's there (she has a location at the Devon and 5th ave place)
#2 is Michaels
#3 is Sammy's
#4 is Olive Grove

For napolese style, Hopkin harvest in windermere is the only place I'll go