Originally Posted by
tirebob
Docking tails I am okay with... If you have ever had a dog with a powerful tail and they break it (like mine did) the results were way worse than if it would have been docked as a puppy. Some working dogs too actually experience damaged tails often and as said, it is a lot harder on a dog who has to have it amputated as an adult than as a pup.
*disclaimer I am not saying this as a cosmetic appeal. Just saying there are situations where with some breeds of dogs and certain situations it makes sense.