I graduated AST back in 1979 and maybe I can clarify some misconceptions. First off the AST program is an excellent program, when completed you will receive the exact same trade certification as completing the apprenticeship program. Yes you also have an AST diploma which is an added benefit if you move away form the automotive industry and into another field.
Starting off, as an apprentice can be a rough ride, finding that first job with a company that wants to hire a 1st year can be difficult, then most often you are sweeping floors, changing tires and doing crap jobs. With the AST program you have greater skills right off the start and walk into jobs easier and usually starting with more technical jobs. Employers are looking for a return on their investment, the sooner an employee is able to generate a profit the sooner your salary will increase. The apprenticeship board regulates wage scale and employers must follow it, if they don’t a simple phone call will correct the oversight.
Yes the AST program contains a lot of theory, in fact twice as much as the apprenticeship program. I personally found this to be a great advantage because you understand the systems and component interactions better, it greatly aids in diagnosis.
As a trade being a mechanic is not the highest paying trade, nor is it the most respected, but it is an honest living that you can make a very comfortable living at.
Volvord 784VC
www.telusplanet.net/public/gilesij/Volvord